twice-baked potatoes with fresh horseradish
When I go out of town, the husband eats frozen pizza and Chipotle and drinks beer. When he goes out of town, apparently I eat enchiladas for four days in a row.
Such is what happened this past weekend, when Elliott was on a trip in Colorado with his friends. He gallivanted around the state snowboarding, hiking and mountain biking. I think there was also a night of camping in Arizona, too? I don’t remember, as I was too busy staring out the window while it snowed making faces like this. I know for sure he didn’t shave, though, as he lovingly reminded me with daily photo updates on my phone.
Obviously by the last night of this most recent separation of ours, I couldn’t take one more bite of leftover enchiladas. And so, these twice-baked potatoes with fresh horseradish graced the single-lady dinner menu. And cheering and dancing and devouring of said potato ensued (look at all the excitement you missed out on, BABE).
Have you ever cooked or baked with fresh horseradish before? Believe it or not, they supply it at my local Cub Foods store (along with cactus leaf, because apparently people eat these things). It’s really an ugly-looking root, but when you peel it and grate it into vinaigrettes and cocktail sauce and these here potatoes, it’s delicious. Sinus-clearing, yes, but delicious.
And actually, about that sinus-clearing: Did you know that when you bake said grated fresh horseradish, the heat reduces its potency? So basically you get the pleasant flavor of horseradish, but without as much of that zing that feels like it burned off your nostril hairs. Two thumbs up for that, I say.
Much as I love a regular baked potato for my single-lady dinners, twice-baked potatoes are just as easy to make and they are just that much fancier and tastier because you can stir the toppings right into the mashed potato. These consist of sour cream, heavy cream, shredded Asiago cheese, chives and the aforementioned horseradish, so the results are extra-smooth, extra-creamy, extra-yummy yum yum. Maybe they tasted just that much better because of all the enchiladas, but I like to think these potatoes stood on their own as an especially good meal.
So next time your significant other decides to leave you on your own for a few days so he/she can camp and bike and run around and get a sunburn because it’s so sunny and warm where he/she is (nope, not bitter), treat yo’ self and make these twice-baked potatoes. It’ll be like your own little vacation to… yummy dinner land. I don’t know.
Prep Time:
Yield:
Print
PinIngredients
- 2 medium russet potatoes, washed and dried
- 2 1/2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
- 1/4 cup plus 1 tablespoon shredded Asiago cheese
- 1/4 cup sour cream, room temperature
- 2 tablespoons half-and-half, room temperature
- 1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon grated fresh horseradish (peel it first)
- 1 tablespoon chopped fresh chives, divided
- Salt and pepper, to taste
Instructions
- Heat oven to 400 degrees F. Poke potatoes all over with a fork. Place directly on center oven rack; bake 50 minutes until potatoes are tender and easily pierced with a fork.
- Holding potatoes with an oven mitt or kitchen towel, slice off the top quarter (lengthwise) of each potato. Use a spoon to carefully scoop out the insides into a large bowl, leaving the skins intact.
- To the bowl, add 2 tablespoons butter. Mash with a fork or potato masher until butter is incorporated. Add 1/4 cup Asiago cheese, sour cream, half-and-half, 1 tablespoon horseradish, 1/2 tablespoon chives and salt and pepper to taste; stir to combine.
- Spoon and mound the potato mixture back into the potato skins. Cut remaining 1/2 tablespoon butter into cubes and place on top of potatoes. Sprinkle tops with remaining 1 tablespoon of Asiago cheese and 1 teaspoon horseradish. Place on a baking sheet or in a baking pan.
- Bake 20 minutes until warmed through and tops are golden brown. Sprinkle with remaining 1/2 tablespoon chopped chives just before serving.
I can normal be found eating tacos/enchiladas in a similar fashion when I’m left home alone. Which are tasty, of course, but somehow don’t feel as special as the meals I cook when it’s two of us. I need to step up my game a bit – these sound (and look) so delicious!
Yum, enchiladas for 4 days straight? Sounds pretty good to me!
Also, these potatoes sound pretty delicious too! I have to find some real horseradish now!
Kathryn — I mean, I do still love enchiladas, but I really failed on mixing them up every night so it got pretty old. I’ll probably eat more enchiladas by this weekend, though. 😉 Thanks!
Tieghan — Ha! Maybe if they were a little different every night and someone else made them for me, I would have enjoyed it more. Don’t get me wrong, though — there are still plenty o’ enchiladas in my future. And yes — find yourself some real horseradish! You’ll love it.
HOLY yum!!! I am all over these babies!
I love horseradish…now all I want is to make these potatoes and eat some enchiladas for breakfast. 🙂
Mexican any night is a bonus for me. I never get to eat ethic cuisine besides Asian!
I must be the only person to love the burn of horseradish in any form in any way. Cream, mayo, salad: you got me hooked. This fiery cheesy potato looks like my kind of single lady dinner too.
When I’m on my own for dinner, my default is breakfast for dinner, but this looks lovely. I adore horseradish, but have been scared to use fresh. Can’t wait to try this.
Ooh I love horseradish but surprisingly have never bought it fresh ha. Good to know you can find it in your local grocery store, putting that on my list next week. Bloody Mary’s anyone?! 😉
I adore these flavors and now I’m craving horseradish!
And Paul totally lives on frozen pizza when I’m out of town!
Idn’t it a hoot that both of you go the Mexican route when you’re not eating together? Two peas in a pod, I say! I’m up for a twice baked tater any ol’ night of the week, given I’m single every night of the week, ha! Asiago cheese is my favvvvorite cheese to use with taters and don’t tell the girl over at The Roasted Root this, but I’ve never cooked with fresh horseradish < – – – tail between legs.
Beautiful recipe, my lady!
Ashley — Thanks, dearie!
Erika — Sounds like a fine plan to me. 😉
Belinda — If you love the burn of horseradish, you’ll love this potato. It’s definitely still got some kick!
Nicole — Oh yes, brinner is another go-to for me, for sure (because the husband doesn’t like waffles — WHAT). You have to try fresh horseradish — you’ll be hooked!
Alexe — Do it! And heck yes to the Bloody Marys!
Cassie — Thanks, dear! And so glad to know my husband isn’t the only one who goes the frozen pizza route. 😉
Julia — Well I’ve never done half of the amazing things you do on your blog, so… I’d say the adventurousness still tips in your favor. 😉
I could definitely do enchiladas four nights in a row. Mmmm mmmm mmmm!! I love twice baked potatoes, but hardly ever make them for some reason, need to change that. Love the horseradish in these!
Due to the fact that I am a single lady, I eat lots of single lady dinners. I am no stranger to eating the same thing night after night because of copious amounts of leftovers. However, I have the feeling I could eat these twice-baked potatoes all week!
I’ve never seen anyone use fresh horseradish before! I pass by it at the farmers market every week and think, “I wonder how you use that…” and now you have answered my most pressing foodie question! So thank you!
These twice baked potatoes look sublime! As it so happens the Hubs is going out of town in a week, so I might just have to whip some of these up!
Ooooo I love horseradish!!! I usually keep a hunk in my freezer. No joke! In our family we eat raw horseradish every Easter. It is to remember the bitterness in the past year. Talk about nostril clearing!!!!
Nicole — The more twice-baked potatoes in your life, the better. It’s science. 😉
Amanda — Truth be told, switching between these and enchiladas, I’d be set on dinners for life. 🙂
Lindsey — Oooh, yes, you should definitely grab some and give it a try! I’m hooked.
Stefanie — Whaaaaat that’s awesome! Love it.
I love twice-baked potatoes and horseradish is a must!
Pingback: The Internet Kitchen: #loveyourleftovers Giveaway! - Macheesmo
This looks awesome. I love your blog!
Laura — Thanks so much, friend!
Abigail — Thank you so much!
I’ve never used fresh horseradish before, but that has to change after seeing these! The flavors sound amazing!
Seriously Marc is the exact same – he won’t cook a meal to save his life when I’m out of town. He runs solely on Chipotle, Jimmy John’s, or the hospital cafeteria…yeck. These potatoes totally look like something I’d make on a night when Marc is working – I LOVE horseradish! In fact, I’ve been devouring a block of Horseradish Havarti cheese this week…it’s incredibly delicious!
My husband eats things like take-out chicken wings, breakfast foods, and drinks beers when I’m gone, and I usually have cold cereal like a boring lady.
I recently had a crazy craving for baked potatoes…these look SO GOOD! I love all the things in this potato situation too. I mean, creamy dairy, cheese, and horseradish plus potatoes cannot fail.
Jessica — You should definitely give it a try! It’s delicious with cheesy carbs. 🙂
Taylor — Oooh, yes, hospital food. Even when I save stuff in the fridge for him; it’s that “leftovers” complex. And horseradish havarti? I WANT.
Cindy — Cereal def makes the rotation for me, too. Eating this potato was super gourmet for my single-lady meal times! 🙂
I love horseradish sauce but have only ever eaten it with roast beef (and probably out of a jar). I can imagine how wonderful it tastes with potato!
Helen — Oh yes, I usually eat it with roast beef too and it’s so yummy — that with this potato on the side? Best dinner ever. 🙂
Yummy dinner land is definitely where I want to be! Whenever the.boy isn’t here for dinner, I eat all kinds of nonsense. Mostly chocolate. But I’m sure I would feel much better noshing on one of these beauties.
That is too funny! When I go out of town, or even if I am just working late my husband always has pizza and beer for dinner and when he goes out of town I usually eat tacos for every meal. I’m always looking for new flavors to use on potatoes and I love the idea of horseradish!
Pingback: Twice Baked Four Leaf Potatoes for St. Paddy’s